REPORTS OF CASES

ARGUED AND DETERMINED

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE

FOR THE

WESTERN DIVISION

APRIL TERM, 1905.

EASTERN DIVISION

SEPTEMBER TERM, 1905.

MIDDLE DIVISION
DECEMBER TERM, 1905.

CHARLES T. CATES, JR.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL AND REPORTER.

VOL. VII.

E. W. STEPHENS, PUBLIsher,
COLUMBIA, MISSOURI,

AND

NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE.

33

Entered according to act of Congress in the year 1906 by

E. W. STEPHENS,

In the office of the Librarian of Congress at Washington, D. C.

Rep. My. 30., 1906

JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT

OF TENNESSEE.

STATE AT LARGE.

W. K. MCALISTER,

M. M. NEIL.

WESTERN DIVISION.

W. D. BEARD, CH. J.

MIDDLE DIVISION.
JOHN S. WILKES.

EASTERN DIVISION.

JOHN K. SHIELDS.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL AND REPORTER

CHARLES T. CATES, JR.,
Knoxville, Tenn.

COURT OF CHANCERY APPEALS OF TENNESSEE.

EASTERN DIVISION.

R. M. BARTON, JR.

MIDDLE DIVISION.

S. F. WILSON.

WESTERN DIVISION.
JOHN M. TAYLOR.

Chattanooga

Huntsville

S. D. MCREYNOLDS, for 6th Circuit
H. CLAY JAMES, for 2d Circuit

'Holds chancery court of Knox county. Appointed to succeed W. C. Houston, resigned. 345Appointed to hold Second, Third and Fourth Divisions of Circuit Court Shelby County, created by Act of 1905.

Appointed to hold Circuit Court, 16th Judicial Circuit, created by Act of 1905,
"Appointed to hold Criminal Court, Second Judicial Circuit, created by Act of 1905.