Cases Reported MILLER V. BASORE ET AL. Decided No. 13209. May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Lorain county. Mr. L. B. Fauver and Mr. R. H. Rice, for plaintiff in error. Mr. George L. Glitsch, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13223. THE VILLAGE OF CADIZ V. TIMMONS. Decided May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Harrison county. Mr. Albert O. Barnes and Mr. R. H. Minteer, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Hollingsworth & Worley, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, JOHNSON, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13233. THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. OF CINCINNATI V. MINCKS ET AL. Decided May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Harrison county. Mr. J. L. Kohl and Messrs. Hollingsworth & Worley, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Albert O. Barnes, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13370. LOOKER ET AL. v. WAdsworth. Decided May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Summit county. Mr. Edward F. Voris and Messrs. Wilcox, Burch & Adams, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Boylan & Brouse, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur. Without Opinion. No. 13870. KRUMM ET AL. v. HARRIS. Decided May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Franklin county. Messrs. Williams, Williams, Taylor & Nash and Mr. W. T. Spear, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Pugh & Pugh and Mr. J. M. Sheets, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur. No. 13973. LOTT V. THE STATE OF OHIO. Decided May 6, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Darke county. Mr. H. L. Yount, for plaintiff in error. Mr. John F. Maher and Mr. L. E. Kerlin, prosecuting attorneys; Mr. A. H. Meeker and Mr. D. W. Bowman, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13137. WESTWATER ET AL., PARTNERS, V. FEDERAL UNION SURETY CO. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Franklin county. Mr. James M. Butler and Mr. J. G. Westwater, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Bennett & Westfall, for defendant in error. Judgment of the circuit court reversed and that of the common pleas affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13140. BELCHER V. RICHART. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Scioto county. Messrs. Holcomb & Millar, for plaintiff Cases Reported in error. Mr. Noah J. Dever, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13143. THE HARDESTY MANUFACTURING Co. v. THE RICE VENEER & LUMBER CO. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Tuscarawas county. Mr. J. G. Patrick, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Ed. C. Seikel, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13161. KUMP V. THE KILBY MANUFACTURING CO. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Cuyahoga county. Mr. C. W. Dille and Mr. H. C. Boyd, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Hoyt, Dustin, Kelley, McKeehan & Andrews, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., DONAHUE, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. WANAMAKER, J., dissents. No. 13163. HUMPHREYS ET AL. V. LOOMIS ET AL. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Summit county. Messrs. Slaybaugh, Seiberling & Huber and Messrs. Lyon & Hunter, for plaintiffs in error. Mr. Edwin F. Voris and Mr. Samuel G. Rogers, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur. Without Opinion. No. 13190. RICE V. THE HOCKING VALLEY RAILWAY CO. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Hocking county. Mr. A. E. Jacobs, for plaintiff in error. Mr. John F. Wilson; Mr. T. S. Hogan and Mr. J. M. McGillivray, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed on ground that verdict for original defendant should have been directed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. WANAMAKER, J., dissents. No. 13191. THE CITY OF CINCINNATI GEORGE & ALLAN. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Hamilton county. Mr. Edward M. Ballard and Mr. Alfred Bettman, city solicitors, and Mr. Geoffrey Goldsmith and Mr. Coleman Avery, assistant city solicitors, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Littleford, James, Frost & Foster, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13226. DONALDSON V. THE CADIZ GAS Co. ET AL. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Harrison county. Mr. R. H. Minteer, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Hollingsworth & Worley, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur. No. 13235. HACKENBERG V. HACKENBERG. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Cases Reported Cuyahoga county. Messrs. Cushing, Siddall & Palmer and Mr. A. E. Powell, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. WANAMAKER, J., dissents. No. 13236. THE SUPERIOR COAL Co. v. THE MACKELDUM MINING CO. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Jefferson county. Mr. T. S. Hogan and Mr. Joseph McGhee, for plaintiff in error. Mr. J. M. McGillivray; Mr. Wallace D. Yaple and Mr. Walter W. Boulger, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur. No. 13244. LONG ET AL., ADMRS., V. LIEBHERR ET AL. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Wood county. Messrs. Bailey & Leasure and Mr. Lawrence F. Conway, for plaintiffs in error. Mr. Edward Beaverstock; Mr. Benjamin F. James and Messrs. McClelland & Bowman, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur. No. 13246. THE CITY OF CINCINNATI V. ARMSTRONG. Decided May 13, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Hamilton county. Mr. Edward M. Ballard and Mr. Alfred Bettman, city solicitors, |