Cases Reported

No. 13262. BRAYTON 7. GALBRONER ET AL. Decided June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Seneca county. Mr. George E. Schroth, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Milton Sayler and Messrs. Platt & Black, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE and WANAMAKER, JJ., concur.

No. 13401. CLAAR ET AL. V. THE CITIZENS SAVINGS & TRUST CO. ET AL. Decided June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Perry county. Mr. C. W. McCleery and Mr. R. U. Wilson, for plaintiffs in error. Mr. J. M. McGillivray; Mr. D. H. Armstrong and Mr. C. A. Donahue, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. Grounds stated in journal entry.

It is ordered and adjudged by this court, that the judgment of the said circuit court be, and the same is hereby, affirmed; for the reason that the errors in the charge of the court of common pleas to the jury are not found by this court to have been prejudicial, this court finding that substantial justice has been done between the parties. JOHNSON, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13407. CURTISS ET AL. V. THE CHARTIERS OIL CO. Decided June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Perry county. Messrs. Booth, Keating, Peters & Pomerene, for plaintiffs in error. Mr. D. N. Postlewaite; Mr. T. P. Linn; Mr. A. L. Thurman; Mr. C. A. Donahue and Messrs.

Without Opinion.

Weil & Thorp, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHauck, C. J., NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13732. THE CITY OF SALEM V. WRIGHT. Decided June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Columbiana county. Mr. S. W. Ramsey and Mr. John E. Scott, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Metzger & Smith and Mr. W. S. Anderson, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHauck, C. J., DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ., concur.

No. 13764. WISE, A TAXPAYER, V. THE CITY OF BARBERTON ET AL. Decided June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Summit county. Mr. O. D. Everhard and Mr. W. E. Young, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Elmer Boden, city solicitor, and Messrs. Rogers, Rowley & Mather, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. WANAMAKER, J., not participating.

No. 13866. MASON 7. THE STATE OF OHIO. Decided June 10, 1913. June 10, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Montgomery county. Messrs. Mattern & Brumbaugh and Mr. W. Z. Davis, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Robert C. Patterson, prosecuting attorney, and Mr. Robert R. Nevin, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

ERROR to Circuit Court Sherman Kulp and Mr.

Decided June 17, 1913. of Huron county. Mr. A. V. Andrews, for plaintiff in error. Mr. A. M. Beattie and Messrs. C. P. & R. D. Wickham, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, DONAHUE and NEWMAN, JJ.,

concur.

No. 13189. THE TOLEDO, BOWLING GREEN & SOUTHERN TRACTION Co. v. BAXTER. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Hancock county. Mr. E. V. Bope, for plaintiff in error. Mr. George H. Phelps, for defendant in error. Judgment of the circuit court reversed and that of the common pleas affirmed. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

AL.

No. 13269. TOWNSEND V. HEILKER ET v. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Hamilton county. Mr. Walter M. Locke, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Galvin & Bauer, for defendants in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13270. POLAND ET AL., TAX COMMISSIONERS OF OHIO, V. THE CINCINNATI, GEORGETOWN & PORTSMOUTH RD. Co. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Franklin county. Mr. Timothy S. Hogan, attorney general; Mr. Clar

Without Opinion.

ence D. Laylin and Mr. J. M. McGillivray, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Dinsmore & Shohl, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13271. POLAND ET AL., TAX COMMISSIONERS OF OHIO V. THE FELICITY & BETHEL RD. Co. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Franklin county. Mr. Timothy S. Hogan, attorney general; Mr. Clarence D. Laylin and Mr. J. M. McGillivray, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Dinsmore & Shohl, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13275. THE COLUMBUS MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE Co. v. FORD. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Geauga county. Mr. Robert S. Parks and Messrs. Sheets, West & Game, for plaintiff in error. Mr. Jay Buchwalter, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13281. MEREDITH ET AL., COMMISSIONERS, ET AL. V. LANDON, ETC. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Delaware county. Mr. E. R. Williams, prosecuting attorney, and Messrs. Jewell & Benton, for plaintiffs in error. Messrs. Marriott, Freshwater & Bliss and Messrs.

Cases Reported

Overturf & Hough, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. DONAHUE, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13286. HUGHES V. THE JOHNSTOWN & CROTON TELEPHONE Co. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Licking county. Messrs. Fitzgibbon & Montgomery, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. Kibler & Kibler, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13287. GREEN V. BALL. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Ashtabula county. Mr. Allen M. Cox and Mr. Stillman F. Kneeland, for plaintiff in error. Messrs. McGiffert & Ullman, for defendant in error. Judgment affirmed. JOHNSON, DONAHUE, WANAMAKER and WILKIN, JJ., concur.

No. 13307. THE AKRON & CHICAGO JUNCTION RD. Co. v. WEEDMAN, EXR. Decided June 17, 1913. ERROR to Circuit Court of Huron county. Messrs. Arrel, Wilson, Harrington & DeFord and Mr. D. W. Severance, for plaintiff in error. Mr. E. M. Palmer and Messrs. C. P. & R. D. Wickham, for defendant in error. Judgment reversed and judgment for plaintiff in error. SHAUCK, C. J., JOHNSON, NEWMAN and WILKIN, JJ., concur. WANAMAKER, J., dissents.