SUPREME COURT OF OHIO For the time commencing January 1, 1913, and ending HON. JOHN A. SHAUCK, CHIEF JUSTICE. HON. JAMES G. JOHNSON, JR., HON. R. M. WANAMAKER, HON. OSCAR W. NEWMAN, HON. J. FOSTER WILKIN, Judges. For the time commencing September 22, 1913, and ending January 1, 1915. HON. HUGH L. NICHOLS, CHIEF JUSTICE.* HON. JOHN A. SHAUCK, HON. JAMES G. JOHNSON, JR., HON. MAURICE H. DONAHUE, HON. R. M. WANAMAKER, HON. OSCAR W. NEWMAN, HON. J. FOSTER WILKIN, Judges. + Assumed office September 1, 1913, succeeding E. Howard Gilkey. JUDGES BY WHOM THE OPINIONS IN THIS VOLUME WERE WRITTEN. MR. SHAUCK, Chief Justice PAGE Hamann, Sheriff, v. Heekin... 207 The State, ex rel. City of Toledo, v. Lynch, Auditor..... 71 MR. SHAUCK, Judge The Central National Fire Insurance Co. v. J. R. Roberts 456 The City of Akron v. Roth.. 456 MR. JOHNSON, Judge Fitzgerald et al., Board of Deputy State Supervisors, etc., v. The City of Cleveland..... 338 Hupp et al. v. The Hock-Hocking Oil & Natural Gas Co... 61 Spengler v. Sonnenberg et al.... 192 Thomas, Jr., v. The Board of Commissioners of Hamilton 489 MR. DONAHUE, Judge Assur, a Taxpayer, v. The City of Cincinnati et al......... 181 283 48 Fitzgerald et al., Board of Deputy State Supervisors, etc., v. The City of Cleveland (dissenting)..... 391 Rabe et al. v. The Board of Education of the Canton School 403 The State of Ohio v. McCoy.. 447 The State, ex rel. City of Toledo, v. Lynch, Auditor (con- 106 MR. WANAMAKER, Judge The Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Co. v. Fouts (dissenting).. 317 The City of Cleveland (concurring)... 362 Gibbs v. Village of Girard................ 34 The State, ex rel. City of Toledo, v. Lynch, Auditor (dis senting) 125 The State, ex rel. Maher, Prosecuting Attorney, v. Baker.. 165 |